Save BIG on 1st three Autoship orders! Sign up by 10/1, see terms* >

Shop by brand

  • $0 - $50+
    $0$25$50+

Plush Toys

(41 results)
Joyhound® Crazy Comfy Realistic Duck Plush Squeaker Dog Toy

Joyhound® Crazy Comfy Realistic Duck Plush Squeaker Dog Toy

(280)
$13.99
Buy 2, get 3rd 50% off ALL dog & cat toys
Enjoy Free Same-day delivery!
+ 1 more
Joyhound® Rip Roarin' Tough® Pickle Plush Squeaker Dog Toy

Joyhound® Rip Roarin' Tough® Pickle Plush Squeaker Dog Toy

(60)
$19.99
Buy 2, get 3rd 50% off ALL dog & cat toys
Enjoy Free Same-day delivery!
+ 1 more
KONG® Floppy Knots Fox Rope Plush Squeaker Dog Toy
2 sizes

KONG® Floppy Knots Fox Rope Plush Squeaker Dog Toy

(967)
$18.99
Options from
Buy 2, get 3rd 50% off ALL dog & cat toys
Enjoy Free Same-day delivery!
+ 1 more
Joyhound Crazy Comfy Flattie Giraffe Crinkle Squeaky Plush Dog Toy

Joyhound Crazy Comfy Flattie Giraffe Crinkle Squeaky Plush Dog Toy

(6)
$9.99
Buy 2, get 3rd 50% off ALL dog & cat toys
Enjoy Free Same-day delivery!
+ 1 more
Multipet® Lamb Chop Plush Squeaker Dog Toy
3 sizes

Multipet® Lamb Chop Plush Squeaker Dog Toy

(957)
$9.99
Options from
Buy 2, get 3rd 50% off ALL dog & cat toys
Enjoy Free Same-day delivery!
+ 1 more
Joyhound® Plush Birthday Dog Toy

Joyhound® Plush Birthday Dog Toy

(18)
$7.00
Buy 2, get 3rd 50% off ALL dog & cat toys
Enjoy Free Same-day delivery!
+ 1 more
Joyhound® Rip Roarin' Tough® Pizza Plush Squeaker Dog Toy

Joyhound® Rip Roarin' Tough® Pizza Plush Squeaker Dog Toy

(688)
$22.99
Buy 2, get 3rd 50% off ALL dog & cat toys
Enjoy Free Same-day delivery!
+ 1 more
Joyhound® Rip Roarin' Tough®' Hot Dog Plush Squeaker Dog Toy

Joyhound® Rip Roarin' Tough®' Hot Dog Plush Squeaker Dog Toy

(315)
$28.99
Buy 2, get 3rd 50% off ALL dog & cat toys
Enjoy Free Same-day delivery!
+ 1 more
KONG® Wild Knots Bear
2 sizes

KONG® Wild Knots Bear

(553)
$18.99
Options from
Buy 2, get 3rd 50% off ALL dog & cat toys
Enjoy Free Same-day delivery!
+ 1 more
KONG® Ali The Alligator Plush Squeaker Dog Toy

KONG® Ali The Alligator Plush Squeaker Dog Toy

(439)
$18.99
Buy 2, get 3rd 50% off ALL dog & cat toys
Enjoy Free Same-day delivery!
+ 1 more
Joyhound® Crazy Comfy Realistic Rabbit Plush Squeaker Dog Toy

Joyhound® Crazy Comfy Realistic Rabbit Plush Squeaker Dog Toy

(200)
$13.99
Buy 2, get 3rd 50% off ALL dog & cat toys
Enjoy Free Same-day delivery!
+ 1 more
KONG® Cozie Spunky Monkey Plush Squeaker Dog Toy

KONG® Cozie Spunky Monkey Plush Squeaker Dog Toy

(472)
$18.99
Buy 2, get 3rd 50% off ALL dog & cat toys
Enjoy Free Same-day delivery!
+ 1 more
Joyhound® Bite Shield™ Protection Plush Squeaker Crinkle Sting Ray Dog Toy

Joyhound® Bite Shield™ Protection Plush Squeaker Crinkle Sting Ray Dog Toy

(224)
$19.99
Buy 2, get 3rd 50% off ALL dog & cat toys
Enjoy Free Same-day delivery!
+ 1 more
Joyhound® Rip Roarin' Tough® Beer Plush Squeaker Dog Toy

Joyhound® Rip Roarin' Tough® Beer Plush Squeaker Dog Toy

(227)
$22.99
Buy 2, get 3rd 50% off ALL dog & cat toys
Enjoy Free Same-day delivery!
+ 1 more
Joyhound® Rip Roarin' Tough® Hamburger Plush Squeaker Dog Toy

Joyhound® Rip Roarin' Tough® Hamburger Plush Squeaker Dog Toy

(437)
$22.99
Buy 2, get 3rd 50% off ALL dog & cat toys
Enjoy Free Same-day delivery!
+ 1 more
TUFFY® Ultimate Tug-O-War Tough Plush Dog Toy

TUFFY® Ultimate Tug-O-War Tough Plush Dog Toy

(777)
$29.99
Buy 2, get 3rd 50% off ALL dog & cat toys
Enjoy Free Same-day delivery!
+ 1 more
Joyhound Crazy Comfy Flattie Bear and Hedge Hog Crinkle Squeaky Plush Dog Toy

Joyhound Crazy Comfy Flattie Bear and Hedge Hog Crinkle Squeaky Plush Dog Toy

(8)
$9.99
Buy 2, get 3rd 50% off ALL dog & cat toys
Enjoy Free Same-day delivery!
+ 1 more
Joyhound Game On Tug Ball W/Handles Dog Toy

Joyhound Game On Tug Ball W/Handles Dog Toy

(42)
$11.99
Buy 2, get 3rd 50% off ALL dog & cat toys
Enjoy Free Same-day delivery!
+ 1 more
TUFFY Barnyard Pig Tough Plush Squeaky Dog Toy, Large

TUFFY Barnyard Pig Tough Plush Squeaky Dog Toy, Large

(28)
$49.99
Buy 2, get 3rd 50% off ALL dog & cat toys
Enjoy Free Same-day delivery!
+ 1 more
TUFFY Jr Bone & Ring Squeaky Plush Dog Toy 2-Pack

TUFFY Jr Bone & Ring Squeaky Plush Dog Toy 2-Pack

(18)
$39.99
Buy 2, get 3rd 50% off ALL dog & cat toys
Enjoy Free Same-day delivery!
+ 1 more
Bite Force Gmason Dilophosaurus Squeaker Crinkle Plush Tough Dog Toy

Bite Force Gmason Dilophosaurus Squeaker Crinkle Plush Tough Dog Toy

(38)
$29.99
Buy 2, get 3rd 50% off ALL dog & cat toys
Enjoy Free Same-day delivery!
+ 1 more
Joyhound Crazy Comfy Flattie Pig Crinkle Squeaky Plush Dog Toy

Joyhound Crazy Comfy Flattie Pig Crinkle Squeaky Plush Dog Toy

(10)
$9.99
Buy 2, get 3rd 50% off ALL dog & cat toys
Enjoy Free Same-day delivery!
+ 1 more
Playology Clucking Hen Chicken Scent Plush Dog Toy, Medium

Playology Clucking Hen Chicken Scent Plush Dog Toy, Medium

(56)
$18.99
Buy 2, get 3rd 50% off ALL dog & cat toys
Enjoy Free Same-day delivery!
+ 1 more
Joyhound Rip Roarin' Tough Whale Dog Toy

Joyhound Rip Roarin' Tough Whale Dog Toy

(213)
$22.99
Buy 2, get 3rd 50% off ALL dog & cat toys
Enjoy Free Same-day delivery!
+ 1 more
Joyhound Rip Roarin' Tough Starfish Dog Toy

Joyhound Rip Roarin' Tough Starfish Dog Toy

(315)
$22.99
Buy 2, get 3rd 50% off ALL dog & cat toys
Enjoy Free Same-day delivery!
+ 1 more
Multipet Squeaky Lamp Chop Loofa Dog Toy

Multipet Squeaky Lamp Chop Loofa Dog Toy

(62)
$11.99
Buy 2, get 3rd 50% off ALL dog & cat toys
Enjoy Free Same-day delivery!
+ 1 more
KONG Shieldz Wildz Fish Shaped Dog Toy

KONG Shieldz Wildz Fish Shaped Dog Toy

(42)
$28.99
Buy 2, get 3rd 50% off ALL dog & cat toys
Enjoy Free Same-day delivery!
+ 1 more
Joyhound Biteshield Raccoon Plush Squeaky Dog Toy

Joyhound Biteshield Raccoon Plush Squeaky Dog Toy

(76)
$19.99
Buy 2, get 3rd 50% off ALL dog & cat toys
Enjoy Free Same-day delivery!
+ 1 more
Joyhound Biteshield Dinosaur Plush Squeaky Dog Toy

Joyhound Biteshield Dinosaur Plush Squeaky Dog Toy

(57)
$19.99
Buy 2, get 3rd 50% off ALL dog & cat toys
Enjoy Free Same-day delivery!
+ 1 more
Bite Force Furocious Frank Kevlar® Tough Plush Dog Toy

Bite Force Furocious Frank Kevlar® Tough Plush Dog Toy

(132)
$24.99
Buy 2, get 3rd 50% off ALL dog & cat toys
Enjoy Free Same-day delivery!
+ 1 more
TUFFY Dolphin Tough Plush Dog Toy

TUFFY Dolphin Tough Plush Dog Toy

(541)
$29.99
Buy 2, get 3rd 50% off ALL dog & cat toys
Enjoy Free Same-day delivery!
+ 1 more
KONG Shakers Bobz Giraffe Dog Toy, Medium

KONG Shakers Bobz Giraffe Dog Toy, Medium

(40)
$23.99
Buy 2, get 3rd 50% off ALL dog & cat toys
Enjoy Free Same-day delivery!
+ 1 more
Multipet Squeaker Mat Lamb Chop Dog Toy

Multipet Squeaker Mat Lamb Chop Dog Toy

(66)
$10.99
Buy 2, get 3rd 50% off ALL dog & cat toys
Enjoy Free Same-day delivery!
+ 1 more
Joyhound Realistic Binded Mallard Duck Dog Toy Plush, Squeaker, XXL

Joyhound Realistic Binded Mallard Duck Dog Toy Plush, Squeaker, XXL

(120)
$18.99
Buy 2, get 3rd 50% off ALL dog & cat toys
Enjoy Free Same-day delivery!
+ 1 more
KONG® Signature Stick with Rope Squeaker Dog Toy

KONG® Signature Stick with Rope Squeaker Dog Toy

(841)
$17.99
Buy 2, get 3rd 50% off ALL dog & cat toys
Enjoy Free Same-day delivery!
+ 1 more
TUFFY® Banana 2-in-1 Tough Plush Dog Toy

TUFFY® Banana 2-in-1 Tough Plush Dog Toy

(765)
$19.99
Buy 2, get 3rd 50% off ALL dog & cat toys
Enjoy Free Same-day delivery!
+ 1 more
Joyhound® Crazy Comfy Realistic Raccoon Flattie Crinkler Squeaker Dog Toy

Joyhound® Crazy Comfy Realistic Raccoon Flattie Crinkler Squeaker Dog Toy

(196)
$18.99
Buy 2, get 3rd 50% off ALL dog & cat toys
Enjoy Free Same-day delivery!
+ 1 more
TUFFY® Tough Plush Alligator Plush Squeaker Dog Toy

TUFFY® Tough Plush Alligator Plush Squeaker Dog Toy

(811)
$29.99
Buy 2, get 3rd 50% off ALL dog & cat toys
Enjoy Free Same-day delivery!
+ 1 more
Bite Force Gmason Pterodactyl Squeaker Crinkle Plush Tough Dog Toy

Bite Force Gmason Pterodactyl Squeaker Crinkle Plush Tough Dog Toy

(39)
$29.99
Buy 2, get 3rd 50% off ALL dog & cat toys
Enjoy Free Same-day delivery!
+ 1 more
Bite Force Gmason Double Monster Squeaker Crinkle Plush Tough Dog Toy

Bite Force Gmason Double Monster Squeaker Crinkle Plush Tough Dog Toy

(8)
$29.99
Buy 2, get 3rd 50% off ALL dog & cat toys
Enjoy Free Same-day delivery!
+ 1 more
  2. 1
  3. 2
*Details available on the Promotional Terms Page.