Autoship just got better! Pick up 1st order or get FREE Same-Day Delivery >

Plush Toys

(10 results)
TUFFY® Ocean Creature Squid Dog Toy - Tough Plush

TUFFY® Ocean Creature Squid Dog Toy - Tough Plush

(712)
$20.99
Buy 2, get 3rd 50% off ALL dog & cat toys (excl. Arcadia Trail)
Enjoy Free Same-day delivery!
+ 1 more
TUFFY® Dolphin Dog Toy - Tough Plush

TUFFY® Dolphin Dog Toy - Tough Plush

(541)
$29.99
Buy 2, get 3rd 50% off ALL dog & cat toys (excl. Arcadia Trail)
Enjoy Free Same-day delivery!
+ 1 more
TUFFY® Banana 2-in-1 Tough Plush Dog Toy

TUFFY® Banana 2-in-1 Tough Plush Dog Toy

(765)
$19.99
Buy 2, get 3rd 50% off ALL dog & cat toys (excl. Arcadia Trail)
Enjoy Free Same-day delivery!
+ 1 more
TUFFY® Tough Plush Alligator Plush Squeaker Dog Toy

TUFFY® Tough Plush Alligator Plush Squeaker Dog Toy

(803)
$29.99
Buy 2, get 3rd 50% off ALL dog & cat toys (excl. Arcadia Trail)
Enjoy Free Same-day delivery!
+ 1 more
TUFFY® Ultimate Tug-O-War Tough Plush Dog Toy

TUFFY® Ultimate Tug-O-War Tough Plush Dog Toy

(771)
$29.99
Buy 2, get 3rd 50% off ALL dog & cat toys (excl. Arcadia Trail)
Enjoy Free Same-day delivery!
+ 1 more
TUFFY® Junior Pig Dog Toy - Tough Plush

TUFFY® Junior Pig Dog Toy - Tough Plush

(835)
$12.97
Buy 2, get 3rd 50% off ALL dog & cat toys (excl. Arcadia Trail)
Enjoy Free Same-day delivery!
+ 1 more
TUFFY® Shark Tough Plush Dog Toy

TUFFY® Shark Tough Plush Dog Toy

(962)
$29.99
Buy 2, get 3rd 50% off ALL dog & cat toys (excl. Arcadia Trail)
Enjoy Free Same-day delivery!
+ 1 more
TUFFY® Barnyard Pig Squeaker Plush Dog Toy

TUFFY® Barnyard Pig Squeaker Plush Dog Toy

(28)
$49.99
Buy 2, get 3rd 50% off ALL dog & cat toys (excl. Arcadia Trail)
Enjoy Free Same-day delivery!
+ 1 more
TUFFY® Jr Bone & Ring Squeaker Dog Toy 2-Pack

TUFFY® Jr Bone & Ring Squeaker Dog Toy 2-Pack

(18)
$39.99
Buy 2, get 3rd 50% off ALL dog & cat toys (excl. Arcadia Trail)
Enjoy Free Same-day delivery!
+ 1 more
TUFFY® Alien Themed Dog Toy- UFO

TUFFY® Alien Themed Dog Toy- UFO

(18)
$14.97
Buy 2, get 3rd 50% off ALL dog & cat toys (excl. Arcadia Trail)
Enjoy Free Same-day delivery!
+ 1 more
  1. 1
Download on the App StoreDownload on the Google Play Store
Copyright © 2026 PetSmart LLC
RecallsTerms of Use Privacy Policy Interest-Based Ads Canada Modern Slavery Act
*See Promotional Terms Page for details. Exclusions may apply. While supplies last. Prices & selection may vary by store & online.