Time to start shopping!
Plush Toys
sort by
Best Sellers
-
New
Whisker City® Peacock Mesh Tail Cat Toy - Plush
Old Price $ 4.99
Treats™ Members Save 15% on Orders $100+ w/ code FLASHSALE; exclusions apply
Buy Any Dog or Cat Food, Save 25% on Select Regular Priced Toy
-
New
Mad Cat Hipster Llama Cat Toy - 2 Pack, Catnip, Silvervine, Plush
Old Price $ 5.99
Treats™ Members Save 15% on Orders $100+ w/ code FLASHSALE; exclusions apply
Buy Any Dog or Cat Food, Save 25% on Select Regular Priced Toy
-
New
Mad Cat Tropical Sloth Cat Toy - 2 Pack, Catnip, Silvervine, Plush
Old Price $ 5.99
Treats™ Members Save 15% on Orders $100+ w/ code FLASHSALE; exclusions apply
Buy Any Dog or Cat Food, Save 25% on Select Regular Priced Toy
-
New
Mad Cat Taco Cat Toy - Catnip, Silvervine, Plush
Old Price $ 2.99
Treats™ Members Save 15% on Orders $100+ w/ code FLASHSALE; exclusions apply
Buy Any Dog or Cat Food, Save 25% on Select Regular Priced Toy
-
New
Petlinks® Happy Nip™ Fun Fins™ Kicker Cat Toy - Silvervine, Catnip, Crinkle
Old Price $ 9.99
Treats™ Members Save 15% on Orders $100+ w/ code FLASHSALE; exclusions apply
Buy Any Dog or Cat Food, Save 25% on Select Regular Priced Toy
-
New
Mad Cat Hot Sauce Cat Toy - Catnip, Silvervine, Plush
Old Price $ 2.99
Treats™ Members Save 15% on Orders $100+ w/ code FLASHSALE; exclusions apply
Buy Any Dog or Cat Food, Save 25% on Select Regular Priced Toy
-
New
Whisker City® Easter Carrot Cat Toy - Catnip, Plush
Old Price $ 5.99
Treats™ Members Enjoy Free Same Day Delivery Powered By Doordash
Treats™ Members Save 15% on Orders $100+ w/ code FLASHSALE; exclusions apply
-
New
Petlinks® Blue Beauty™ Lush Plush Cat Toy
Old Price $ 5.99
Treats™ Members Save 15% on Orders $100+ w/ code FLASHSALE; exclusions apply
Buy Any Dog or Cat Food, Save 25% on Select Regular Priced Toy
-
New
Mad Cat Pouncing Pickle Cat Toy - Catnip, Plush
Old Price $ 15.99
Treats™ Members Save 15% on Orders $100+ w/ code FLASHSALE; exclusions apply
Buy Any Dog or Cat Food, Save 25% on Select Regular Priced Toy
-
New
Whisker City® Realistic Fish Cat Toy - (COLOR VARIES)
Old Price $ 1.79
Treats™ Members Save 15% on Orders $100+ w/ code FLASHSALE; exclusions apply
Buy Any Dog or Cat Food, Save 25% on Select Regular Priced Toy
-
New
Whisker City® Spring Easter Bunny Cat Toy - Catnip
Old Price $ 5.99
Treats™ Members Enjoy Free Same Day Delivery Powered By Doordash
Treats™ Members Save 15% on Orders $100+ w/ code FLASHSALE; exclusions apply
-
New
Whisker City® Unicorn Refillable Cat Toy - Catnip, Plush
Old Price $ 7.49
Treats™ Members Save 15% on Orders $100+ w/ code FLASHSALE; exclusions apply
Buy Any Dog or Cat Food, Save 25% on Select Regular Priced Toy
-
New
Petlinks® Happy Nip™ Leggy Loon Dangler Cat Toy - Silvervine, Catnip
Old Price $ 4.99
Treats™ Members Save 15% on Orders $100+ w/ code FLASHSALE; exclusions apply
Buy Any Dog or Cat Food, Save 25% on Select Regular Priced Toy
-
New
Multipet® Lamb Chop Cat Toy - Catnip, Plush, Squeaker
Old Price $ 5.99
Treats™ Members Save 15% on Orders $100+ w/ code FLASHSALE; exclusions apply
Buy Any Dog or Cat Food, Save 25% on Select Regular Priced Toy
-
New
FouFou Brands Holiday Cat Stocking Cat Toy
Old Price $ 6.97
Treats™ Members Enjoy Free Same Day Delivery Powered By Doordash
Treats™ Members Save 15% on Orders $100+ w/ code FLASHSALE; exclusions apply
-
New
Whisker City® Valentine's Day XO Heart Cat Toy - Plush
Old Price $ 2.47
Treats™ Members Enjoy Free Same Day Delivery Powered By Doordash
Treats™ Members Save 15% on Orders $100+ w/ code FLASHSALE; exclusions apply
-
Whisker City® Wine Kicker Catnip Cat Toy
Old Price $ 9.99
Treats™ Members Enjoy Free Same Day Delivery Powered By Doordash
Treats™ Members Save 15% on Orders $100+ w/ code FLASHSALE; exclusions apply
-
Whisker City® Watermelon Kicker Cat Toy - Catnip, Plush
Old Price $ 9.99
Treats™ Members Enjoy Free Same Day Delivery Powered By Doordash
Treats™ Members Save 15% on Orders $100+ w/ code FLASHSALE; exclusions apply
-
Whisker City® Rainbow Monster Kicker Cat Toy - Catnip, Crinkle
Old Price $ 9.99
Treats™ Members Enjoy Free Same Day Delivery Powered By Doordash
Treats™ Members Save 15% on Orders $100+ w/ code FLASHSALE; exclusions apply
-
Smart Pet Love Snuggle Kitty™ Behavioral Aid Cat Toy
Old Price $ 49.99
Treats™ Members Enjoy Free Same Day Delivery Powered By Doordash
Treats™ Members Save 15% on Orders $100+ w/ code FLASHSALE; exclusions apply
-
Whisker City® Sloth Kicker Cat Toy - Catnip, Plush
Old Price $ 9.99
Treats™ Members Enjoy Free Same Day Delivery Powered By Doordash
Treats™ Members Save 15% on Orders $100+ w/ code FLASHSALE; exclusions apply
-
Whisker City® Pickle Cat Toy - Catnip, Plush
Old Price $ 3.99
Treats™ Members Enjoy Free Same Day Delivery Powered By Doordash
Treats™ Members Save 15% on Orders $100+ w/ code FLASHSALE; exclusions apply
-
Whisker City® Hipcat Takeout Cat Toys - 3 Pack
Old Price $ 8.49
Treats™ Members Save 15% on Orders $100+ w/ code FLASHSALE; exclusions apply
Sign In & Enjoy Free Shipping On Orders $49+ | Pick Up Curbside| Shipping Delays May Occur
-
Whisker City® Fluff Balls Cat Toys - 3 Pack
Old Price $ 6.49
Treats™ Members Enjoy Free Same Day Delivery Powered By Doordash
Treats™ Members Save 15% on Orders $100+ w/ code FLASHSALE; exclusions apply
-
Whisker City® Goofy Bird Cat Toy - Catnip
Old Price $ 2.97
Treats™ Members Enjoy Free Same Day Delivery Powered By Doordash
Treats™ Members Save 15% on Orders $100+ w/ code FLASHSALE; exclusions apply
-
Whisker City® Birds with Tails Cat Toys - 2 Pack
Old Price $ 3.87
Treats™ Members Enjoy Free Same Day Delivery Powered By Doordash
Treats™ Members Save 15% on Orders $100+ w/ code FLASHSALE; exclusions apply
-
OurPets® Candy Cat Toy (COLOR VARIES)
Old Price $ 2.37
Treats™ Members Enjoy Free Same Day Delivery Powered By Doordash
Treats™ Members Save 15% on Orders $100+ w/ code FLASHSALE; exclusions apply
-
Whisker City® Hipcat School Mice Cat Toys - 2 Pack
Old Price $ 7.49
Treats™ Members Save 15% on Orders $100+ w/ code FLASHSALE; exclusions apply
Sign In & Enjoy Free Shipping On Orders $49+ | Pick Up Curbside| Shipping Delays May Occur
-
Petlinks® HappyNip™ Cutie Bandit™ Flying Racoon Cat Toy - Catnip
Old Price $ 5.97
Treats™ Members Enjoy Free Same Day Delivery Powered By Doordash
Treats™ Members Save 15% on Orders $100+ w/ code FLASHSALE; exclusions apply
-
Whisker City® Silverfrenzy™ Parrot Feather Cat Toy
Old Price $ 4.47
Treats™ Members Enjoy Free Same Day Delivery Powered By Doordash
Treats™ Members Save 15% on Orders $100+ w/ code FLASHSALE; exclusions apply
-
Whisker City® Hipcat Retro Game Cat Toy - Catnip, Plush
Old Price $ 4.99
Treats™ Members Save 15% on Orders $100+ w/ code FLASHSALE; exclusions apply
Sign In & Enjoy Free Shipping On Orders $49+ | Pick Up Curbside| Shipping Delays May Occur
-
Whisker City® Fish Kicker Cat Toy - Catnip, Plush
Old Price $ 10.49
Treats™ Members Enjoy Free Same Day Delivery Powered By Doordash
Treats™ Members Save 15% on Orders $100+ w/ code FLASHSALE; exclusions apply
-
Whisker City® Silverfrenzy™ Cardinal Cat Toy
Old Price $ 4.47
Treats™ Members Enjoy Free Same Day Delivery Powered By Doordash
Treats™ Members Save 15% on Orders $100+ w/ code FLASHSALE; exclusions apply
-
Meowijuana® Catnip Cigar Cat Toy - Plush (COLOR VARIES)
Old Price $ 6.57
Treats™ Members Enjoy Free Same Day Delivery Powered By Doordash
Treats™ Members Save 15% on Orders $100+ w/ code FLASHSALE; exclusions apply
-
Petstages® Dental Banana Teether Cat Toy
Old Price $ 5.99
Treats™ Members Enjoy Free Same Day Delivery Powered By Doordash
Treats™ Members Save 15% on Orders $100+ w/ code FLASHSALE; exclusions apply
-
Petstages® Macaroons Cat Toys - 3 Pack
Old Price $ 9.99
Treats™ Members Save 15% on Orders $100+ w/ code FLASHSALE; exclusions apply
Sign In & Enjoy Free Shipping On Orders $49+ | Pick Up Curbside| Shipping Delays May Occur
- 1
- 2
